Supreme Court Considers Whether to End Birthright Citizenship

On May 15th of 2025, the Supreme Court began to consider whether to end birthright citizenship in the United States. Some sources describe this case as “historic,” and it’s clear that there’s much at stake. Although this case is only just beginning in earnest, it’s worth keeping a close eye on its progress – especially if you might be affected by the end of birthright citizenship. This might also be a good opportunity to discuss your situation with an experienced immigration lawyer in Palm Beach Gardens.

Opposing Arguments Voiced in Supreme Court 

The Supreme Court case kicked off with opposing arguments from the two sides. The U.S. Solicitor General argued that the lower courts had overstepped their authority. One might argue that the people of the United States elected a new administration to change the current immigration system. One of the key campaign promises of this new administration was to end birthright citizenship. Some have pointed out that if a lower court judge can prevent this administration from delivering on these promises, this undermines democracy in the United States.

On the other side, the New Jersey Solicitor General argued that the loss of birthright citizenship would create mayhem and disarray. The main argument is that ending birthright citizenship would be a major departure from a longstanding Supreme Court precedent. For many years, the Supreme Court has maintained that the 14th Amendment states that “all persons born in the United States” are citizens, regardless of their parents.

Many Are Predicting That Birthright Citizenship Will End

 The challenge for those trying to maintain birthright citizenship is simple: There are too many conservative judges on the Supreme Court. Many of these conservative judges will back the president, and it seems likely that this effort will be successful. Although this case may continue for some time before a final decision, immigrants should prepare themselves for the worst.

What Happens if Birthright Citizenship Ends? 

If birthright citizenship ends, no one will be able to pursue a green card after being born in the United States. In other words, “anchor babies” will cease to have citizenship rights in the United States. Being born in the United States will no longer guarantee you a pathway to citizenship.

The real question is whether this new executive order would apply retroactively. In other words, could you lose your citizenship if you previously acquired it through birthright? The answer is almost certainly “no,” as the logistics of such a move would be almost unthinkable.

Can a Palm Beach Gardens Immigration Lawyer Help Me? 

The potential end of birthright citizenship could have serious implications for countless people throughout the United States. That said, this development could have different effects for different people. If you’re concerned about what might happen next, consider speaking with an experienced immigration attorney in Palm Beach County. Contact The Devore Law Group today to learn more.

Sources: 

bbc.com/news/articles/cm2yer83120o

cnn.com/politics/live-news/supreme-court-birthright-citizenship-cases-05-15-25

aljazeera.com/news/2025/5/15/whats-at-stake-in-us-supreme-court-birthright-citizenship-case